Someone is doing it wrong.
Nope.
Shortly after you reported the route (top-rope, 5.10a) I repeated it. I thought it was a little stiff for 5.10a, and that therefore, 5.10a was just the right rating
Since then I've done or tried it with both Dawsons about two years ago and then again yesterday with Gavin. Both Dawsons (known lightweights, BTW - but don't tell 'em I said that) thought it was really hard. Yesterday I stopped climbing it, since I was warming up and it was too much for a warmup. Then Gavin struggled on it but got it. Fifteen minutes later he walked up The Verdict.
Go try it yourself again (maybe that Sunday of M.O.M.?). One huge hold is still about to come off.