Jake
totally understand. it's not about the ratings, but the type and quality of the rock, type of climbing, and our own style. I think we're all built in ways that favor the types of climbs we gravitate toward.
I'm on my way to the valley in the morning for 4 days of climbing and because I like to climb things I haven't done before, and many of the longer routes are either wet or require trampling through snow, I may be looking at some of the wide polished climbs I've avoided.
I'm thinking your approach sounds good. Maybe I'll wander around, 'warm up' on something easy I've done a number of times, have lunch, and run laps on a TR. you may have something there.